The Test-Optional Era — and What’s Changing

In recent years, college admissions has experienced one of its most significant shifts: the rise of test-optional and test-blind policies. At one point, it seemed like standardized testing might become a relic of the past. Many colleges adopted test-optional policies, hoping to level the playing field, reduce student stress, or respond to unique circumstances such as the COVID-19 pandemic.

But the landscape continues to evolve, reminding us that wisdom, discernment, and trust in God are essential as families navigate these decisions.

Some elite schools are reinstating test requirements - While test-optional policies were intended to open doors, some of the most selective institutions, including Yale University and Brown University, have reinstated standardized test requirements. These decisions reflect data showing that test scores can still help predict student success. Many other colleges are also reinstituting standardized test score policies a part of the required application process.  Even those college that are still test optional, scholarships are most often tied to test scores.

Test-optional policies do not automatically ensure equity - Research shows that even during the test-optional period, elite colleges continued to receive large numbers of high-scoring applicants, and reduced emphasis on scores did not automatically increase diversity in applicant pools.

Test-blind admissions remain rare - Full “test-blind” policies, where scores are completely ignored, remain uncommon. High scores can still be an advantage in a test-optional environment. This reality encourages families to practice wise stewardship: making thoughtful, informed decisions, doing their due diligence, and trusting that God will guide them regardless of the outcome. Scripture consistently reminds us that God calls us to do what we are able while He handles what is beyond our control. For example, when Moses faced the Red Sea with the Israelites on one side and the Egyptian army on the other, God instructed him to raise his staff. While God did not need Moses to lift it to part the waters, He expected obedience and effort. The same principle applies to testing: students should prepare diligently and give their best effort, then trust God with the results, knowing He will lead them along the path He has prepared.

A faith-centered approach to navigating the test-optional era - Ultimately, the test-optional era highlights both opportunity and complexity. God calls us to focus on growth, diligence, and integrity rather than being consumed by competition or fear. Seeking God’s guidance, praying for wisdom, and remembering that true success is measured not by a test score or college name—but by character, faithfulness, and the ways we serve others—can bring peace in the midst of uncertainty.

In this ever-changing admissions landscape, families can walk forward with confidence, trusting God’s plan, pursuing excellence with integrity, and cultivating resilience, purpose, and joy along the journey.